LINDA is a butterfly.
ELENA is a butterfly too: a drunk one.
CAROLINE is a caterpillar, then a butterfly.
[LINDA and ELENA are center stage with giant butterfly wings.
ELENA is drinking and smoking.]
ELENA
Listen, Linda.
LINDA
I’m listening.
ELENA
I’m not going this year. You can lead them, you know the way. I can’t fly after all the shit I’ve seen.
LINDA
But we need you –
ELENA
Seen! HA! Like it wasn’t my fault!
LINDA
It’s not! You’re moved by the wind as much as you move the wind yourself.
ELENA
Wind, don’t remind me. Fucking tornadoes. Storms. Remember Hurricane Hugo? That was a shit show.
LINDA
You couldn’t have known.
ELENA
No, but storm clouds were forming when I took off. And by the time I landed, I’d set things in motion for Hurricane Andrew three years later. Total fucking disaster.
LINDA
We go through this every year: it might have been a thousand times worse if you hadn’t flown that day.
ELENA
I was hungry. I wanted some lilac. [LINDA mouths along:] But we had some milkweed in the fridge that was about to expire. I could’ve just had that for dinner.
LINDA
When are you going to forgive yourself? For all you know, you’re causing another hurricane right now by sitting here being miserable. [ELENA takes a swig.] Besides, migration starts in the morning.
ELENA
Fucking butterflies, huh? An elephant can tromp through the forest and knock over trees and spray water everywhere like an ASSHOLE, but no one talks about the elephant effect. But I flap one wing…
LINDA
Your wings are so beautiful.
ELENA
One wing and everyone’s buying a week’s worth of bottled water and dusting off their diesel generators. My “beautiful wings” might as well be horsemen 1 and 2 of the apocalypse.
LINDA
On my first trip south I didn’t take my eyes off of them the whole way.
ELENA
I mean I get that things have to move forward. I’m not trying to uninvent the wheel here. But every newscast these days makes me feel like I’m on trial.
LINDA
We have to leave when the sun rises.
ELENA
I’m staying behind this time. I was meant to fly, not decide the course of history. I’ll take my chances with the cold, thanks. Play out the string puddling and smoking horseweed.
LINDA
You’ll die –
ELENA
One wing… Cain and Abel walk out of that field together. After that it was stop moving, or stop caring.
LINDA
But you can’t stop moving.
ELENA
I didn’t. I flew all over the world. Never felt as free in my life. [pause.] Thought about it, though. Thought about finding a patch of thistle, eating ‘til it ran out. And now, that’s what I’m going to do.
LINDA
Butterfly. That’s what we do.
ELENA
Hurricanes and despots. We do those too. I just wished I’d warned you –
LINDA
I knew what I was getting into.
ELENA
You did?
LINDA
You hear a lot when you’re wrapped up in that chrysalis. I heard you all those nights crying about the space shuttle, the plague… but I had to try it. I had to –
ELENA
Of course. The winds were already swelling under you when you first stuck your head out.
LINDA
I thought I could find the right flight path. Hover just long enough over the right flower, blow the scattered pieces of the shuttle back together… seems so silly now.
ELENA
You go fly, you keep at it.
LINDA
If I had wings like yours, I don’t know if I could stop myself.
ELENA
You’re so sweet.
[CAROLINE emerges. She has smaller wings and is covered in thick liquid.
SHE starts to explore the stage/world.]
ELENA
Kid do NOT move your wings. Stay perfectly still.
CAROLINE
But –
ELENA
I will shove you right back in that cocoon if you so much as flutter.
CAROLINE
It’s not a cocoon, it’s –
LINDA
Hello.
CAROLINE
Hello. [THEY look to ELENA, who rolls her EYES]
ELENA
Hello. [She is extremely put upon.] Welcome to our habitat. You’re probably related to us. Don’t get too comfortable – winter is coming.
LINDA
Come now. Dry yourself off, have some goldenrod, and stay upright as long as you can. Tomorrow’s a big day. [pause] And don’t be intimidated. [gestures at ELENA.] She’ll sober up soon, and she’s the sweetest thing I’ve ever met.
CAROLINE
She doesn’t seem sweet.
ELENA
Do whatever you want with your wings, kid. Just know that if they’re anything like mine, they’ll destroy a whole hell of a lot of beautiful things. Nothing good can come out of them.
LINDA
Your wings are every serendipitous scientific discovery, all the ink flowing a pen one way instead of another, they’re all the paintings in the world; your wings are penicillin and Leaves of Grass and Starry Night.
ELENA
My wings are atoms splitting and Mein Kampf and paint splashed haphazardly on a canvas.
CAROLINE
Sometimes paint splashed on a canvas is Jackson Pollack.
LINDA
[pause.] How do you know about Jackson Pollack?
CAROLINE
We learned about him in caterpillar school.
ELENA
No. Pollack had control over every drip. He was order. We are chaos.
CAROLINE
It doesn’t look like he had control over every –
LINDA
Your wings are the reason I wake up from my quiescence every morning.
ELENA
Stop it.
LINDA
It’s true.
CAROLINE
Is it time for quiescence soon? I’m getting awfully tired.
LINDA
Soon enough. [to ELENA] Come on now, we have to pack.
CAROLINE
Can I help?
ELENA
How can you help? You don’t know how important every movement is now. You can’t just slink around like you used to.
CAROLINE
I can help. I was voted most likely to… help, in school, and I loved the library so much that I volunteered on my local branch! I’m very helpful!
ELENA
Well aren’t you just a caterpillar of the community.
LINDA
You did not just say that.
ELENA
I did. I did! [laughs, breaks. ELENA and LINDA laugh. Maybe embrace.]
CAROLINE
I don’t get it.
ELENA
Oh honey.
CAROLINE
Who’s Hurricane Hugo?
ELENA
You heard all that?
CAROLINE
Yes. He doesn’t sound very nice.
ELENA
Oh honey, he wasn’t. He was a real, honest-to-goodness hurricane. And I made –
LINDA
You made straight for the plains the second he started spinning. His wind was strong, but you pushed back as hard as you could. And because of the way you flew that night, some people made it into their shelters in time, some people fell in love, and someone made some comment in passing to a nine-year-old. She’s 34 now, finishing a rotation in oncology. And in 10 years when she’s sequencing genomes in her lab, the nucleotides will spell out a new word. A word with new letters. A word that is the opposite of “metastasize”. And she couldn’t have read that word – the most important word in medical history since “anesthesia” – but for what she heard when the storm sirens went off in 1989.
CAROLINE
You did all that?
ELENA
A lot happened that night.
LINDA
A lot happens every night. You can only try your best, and hope it works out.
ELENA
There’s a flight path that will lead to the greatest love shared by the greatest number of people.
LINDA
And there’s a flight path that will lead to immeasurable pain for everyone. And when that possibility stares you in the face, you have to stare right back.
CAROLINE
So what do we do?
ELENA
We try.
LINDA
We fly.
ELENA
She’s right. We fly and flutter in all good faith, and hope for the best. [pause] This might just be crazy enough to work.
[ELENA goes to the ground to get ready for the next step, which is either…ENDING 1
[CAROLINE is off stage, “hidden”, when this begins. SHE has shed her wings, and ELENA and LINDA lose them throughout the scene, wind up in clothes of mourning.]
LINDA
You’ve got to get up. You can do it.
ELENA
Yeah, OK, OK, let’s go. [THEY start to leave. ELENA crumples.] I had his keys in my hand.
LINDA
I know. And he looked you right in the eye, and spoke as clear as the wind.
ELENA
I thought I’d… you know… talk to him about it after. Like, the next morning.
LINDA
You couldn’t have known.
ELENA
I can’t look at them. That’s why I came back here, I –
CAROLINE
[ELENA is interrupted by CAROLINE, who’s been listening.] I know it’s hard for you to see me right now.
ELENA
I’m –
CAROLINE
[CAROLINE waves ELENA off.] I know. I will miss him every day of my life. I loved him more than –
But. They found another bottle under the seat. Empty. And another one in the glove – where the glove compartment used to be. And another –
Listen to me. He did this. Not you. You don’t know how it would’ve turned out if… I mean Jessica was supposed to get a ride from … I love him so much, and I hate to say this, but… single car? No passengers? And it was instant, they said. It was instant, they…
[LINDA goes to embrace CAROLINE.]
ELENA
But I could’ve –
CAROLINE
[waves ELENA off] No. No.
ELENA
You’re so sweet. But I don’t know what I’m going to do.
LINDA
Well, the first thing you’re going to do is get off the ground. After that we can wing it…
[ELENA starts to rise.]
[lights fade to BLACK]
ENDING 2:
LINDA
Let’s go. Flap those beautiful wings. [THEY start flying.]
ELENA
Oh this feels so good already.
CAROLINE
I don’t know how to do it!
ELENA
Don’t overthink, kid. Just start flapping.
CAROLINE
I don’t want to get lost!
LINDA
You can do this. Just keep your eyes trained on her wings.
ELENA
Follow her wings, kid. She’ll show you everything you need to know. [THEY are flying.]
CAROLINE
Look at those clouds.
LINDA
You’re as strong as they are.
ELENA
See all those seeds stirring around?
CAROLINE
It’s beautiful up here.
ELENA
It is.
LINDA
It is.
CAROLINE
You guys?
ELENA
Yeah kid?
CAROLINE
Is this the opposite of “metastasize?”
[Lights fade to black]